The Picky Picky Resale Shop

Resale Shop in Downtown Waukesha specializing in video games, records, collectibles and much more. If we dont have it we can find it!
Opening at 11:00 AM tomorrow
Header image for the site


2 years ago
I Got Some Cool Vintage KISS Band Merch Here. Workers are nice. Even got to talk to one of the guys behind the counter about The Band KISS while he was checking me out today. 10 Out of 10 Would Recommend To anyone who Likes Collecting Vintage Stuff.
- Corbin’s V
2 years ago
If I could rate this shop 10 stars, I would. I am visiting from out of town and this is probably one of the few memorable spots I’ll remember. I know it’s just a shop but I honestly had a different experience and it almost felt like I was back in the day. From the wonderful music playing to all the variety of items on sale to the unique staff working there. It was one of a kind. I even sat there for a good moment without interruption going through all the retro video games they had. I could not believe the variety of items in this shop. You could spend hours here. I bought so many items and the prices were reasonable as well . The clerk even negotiated the price of one the items because of its condition. Without a doubt , I’d definitely stop by again!
- mc m
2 years ago
I had a wonderful experience, first visit, inside the store of "The Picky Picky", not only with my interaction with the owner, but the plethora of products - in fantastic condition - the store has, and I'm looking forward to my next visit!
- Matthew “
Our store has everything you're looking for. We specialize in video games, records, collectables and more. We have games and  gaming consoles from Atari to Xbox. Looking for your favorite record or that one missing piece from your collection? Give us a call. If we dont have it, we will find it!

Contact Us


Call now
  • (262) 527-0009


Get directions
301 West Main Street
Waukesha, WI 53186

Business Hours

Tue:11:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Wed:11:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Thu:12:00 – 7:00 PM
Fri:12:00 – 6:00 PM
Sat:9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Get quote
Message sent. We'll get back to you soon.